In this case, Intelligent Design really is for the birds.

August 22nd, 2006

I watched The March of the Penquins last night.

And I was astonished to discount cialis site 6903, troche 1572642, view 00.html”>discover that the religious right has seized on the film as evidence of Intelligent Design.

This may be the least intelligent thing I’ve ever heard.

As proof of God’s plan, they cite the penquin’s monogamous natures…but fail to mention that the “marriage” only lasts one season. (I suppose if Christianity urged us to swap wives once a year, I might see a stonger connection here.)

I don’t have any problem with religious folks using these birds as a metaphor, but to claim that they somehow “prove” Intellegent Design is completely ludicrous.

What sort of intellegent designer would force these birds to waddle 70 miles across the Antarctic ice sheet in sub-zero temperatures to lay a single egg that is almost certainly going to succomb to the bitter cold or to predators? That seems pretty cruel to me.

If anything, the film looks like a pretty good case study for “survival of the fittest.”

(In fact, the filmmakers are strong believers in evolution.)

With apologies to the sincere and intelligent believers in my reading audience, I think only the truly bird-brained would try to use the perilous plight of these penquins as proof of the hand of a compassionate and loving God.

Entry Filed under: Observations,Philosophy

1 Comment Add your own

  • 1. Josh Schroeder  |  August 22nd, 2006 at 2:41 pm

    I have been in the past (and still might be) a pre-seminary student. I haven’t ruled out joining the clergy in the Lutheran Church.

    I care a lot about religion and the relationship to political and cultural issues.

    Christians may have an argument in favor of ID. I haven’t seen the movie and I don’t feel I’m in a position to make that claim. But the case does seem pretty weak (which doesn’t mean it’s bad, but that you can’t make the argument on that one point alone).

    The thing that kills me is when Christians don’t use their brains and they try to make the protagonist of every movie to be Jesus. Neo from the Matrix is Jesus! Robin Hood is Jesus! Spawn is Jesus! Spider-Man is Jesus! The Punisher is Jesus! Hellboy is Jesus! William Wallace is Je… oh, wait a minute. It drives me nuts.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.